What I'm Wearing:

                 I styled myself! Brandy&Melville tee, American Apparel bodysuit, Forever 21 cutoffs, Frye platforms

It was really nice to come back from a much-needed vacation and see first thing that my picture with the lovely Laura Anne made the cover of The Modern Magazine's June issue! Thanks to the amazing Harley Hall who managed with minimal lights, equipment and mostly just the ambience of Central Park in spring to make that happen. His beautiful wife did all our makeup, and I did my own hair using a set of cheap hot curlers I bought from Duane Reade years ago. The theme was 70s-inspired, so I wore feather earrings I purchased at a native American reservation in Oregon and my favorite blue wolf tee you'll probably see lots more times if you regularly read my blog (which I hope you will :)).
It was especially nice to receive good news, because a few weeks before I left for vacation something not so good happened on a professional shoot. Something that made me finally decide it was time to take my first real vacation in years... Basically, I needed time to think about what I was doing with my life. The more successful I've become as a model the more pressure I've felt to lose weight. I always said (to myself, my family and my friends) that if the pressure became too much for me I'd quit modeling.  But decisions like that can get complicated when then there are jobs like the one above with Harley et al where everyone is lovely and relaxed and no one does anything but be super-duper nice to me and fun to work with. 

I think if I had a slightly different temperament it might be easier for me to focus on those good times and let the criticisms and bad times roll off my back, but I can't be anyone but myself. And I like me (in the non-narcissistic, healthy self-esteem kind of way-- I hope). Everyone who knows me well characterizes me both as very sensitive and very caring, so why would I want to change that to do better at my job? It makes me think that perhaps I should change my job instead. 

My thinking has especially followed those lines since reading Tyra Banks' open letter to models regarding Vogue's recent decision to ban images of anorexia. I feel as if my difficulty with the weight issue and its attendant criticisms is less a personal flaw and more symbolic of changing times. The fashion world has reset to zero and girls like me-- size 4 girls who are healthy and happy-- are seen as "retro" (I book a LOT of jobs like the one above playing 70s girls) or (frequently) as "fat". 

Here's the excerpt from Tyra's letter that's really made me think about what I'm doing:

Many of you have graciously said that you want to have the same type of career that I’ve had. But the truth is that if I was just starting to model at age 17 in 2012, I could not have had the career that I did. I would’ve been considered too heavy. In my time, the average model’s size was a four or six.  Today you are expected to be a size zero. When I started out, I didn’t know such a size even existed.

I
am modeling in 2012 and I am a healthy size 4 and I don't want to change that. Nor could I if I tried. I cannot function without food. There have been times I've tried liquid diets and within 36 hours I felt woozy, light-headed and very, very angry. 

Here's what happened that got me thinking: a few weeks ago I shot  a campaign for a very famous salon here in New York. The other girls were all size zeros, and I'm not really sure why they booked me since I'm clearly not. Except perhaps because the photographer did the booking, and he's a man. Men seem to see less of a problem with girls possessing curves. The campaign coordinator on the other hand was a woman, and she saw plenty of problems with it. Whenever her dissatisfied eyes fell on me, they spoke volumes. Each time she'd ask me as if it were the first time if I was sure I could fit into the clothes. The clothes were a size 2 and 4, and I easily fit them versus having to be pinned into them like the other girls off of whom the dresses and blouses hung making them look like little girls dressing up in their mother's clothes. 

Then what few things I had going for me (like a healthy head of hair) really fell apart: the owner of the salon trimmed my bangs while they were wet (a basic rule of bang no-no), adding thick chunks to my bangs, and the result was awful. My bangs were so thick bits of them stuck straight out and the rest-- a straight-across ridge of coarse dark hair-- cast severe shadows over my face. Everyone, the other models, the beauticians, told me I looked terrible. Losing her patience with my "look" (horrible industry speak for a person's appearance), which displeased her now from head to toe, not to mention had grated on her nerves these  twelve hours (from 8:30 a.m. when I arrived that morning till nearly 8 that night), the salon coordinator snapped: "Don't bother putting makeup on her; we're just going to shoot the back of her head."

When I left the salon, I began to cry and cry. Not only did I feel humiliated in front of the size zero girls (some of whom I'd worked with before and one of whom comforted me by saying: "You photograph much thinner and taller than you look in real life." (And then later wistfully added she wished she had friends, while I wondered if it would be catty to point out to her: "You photograph much sweeter than you act in real life. Could be your problem making friends there.") I also felt as if I'd let myself down on a really fundamental level by not having politely excused myself and leaving after the fifth time the shoot coordinator asked me if I was sure the turquoise pencil skirt I was wearing (and rocking might I add) really fit.

On the bright side, as Lena Dunham's character "Hannah" from Girls might say about living through a humiliating experience: "At least it gives me something to write about."

The past few weeks spent driving across country helped me have a little more perspective on "the incident" as I've come to call it. As we sped past miles and miles of wheat fields and cows and lush, green forests, I did a lot of thinking and let go of a lot of the negative emotions that were clouding my thoughts. It especially helped when we finally made it to the thin, cold airy land of Colorado where the mountains reign supreme across the sky looking like hunched-up old Zen masters shaking their hoary heads over all our twittering trivial issues. I realized that  ultimately what really bothers me is having my own vision and ideals superseded by a world view I don't agree with: I don't think size 4 is fat, yet I do feel fat. And I don't think it's okay to treat people like objects, yet I allowed myself to be objectified.

I'm not sure if being the industry's only, lonely size 4 model in 2012 is a worthy cause to commit myself to, but I know that's at least where I'm at... until I can find a worthier one anyway. But I guess I'll have to figure out where I'm going along the way.

And lacking my own conclusions, I'd love to hear other women's thoughts on this topic. Thank you in advance for your support and comments.
P.S. On a happier note I wanted to share with those who've been following my blog the wonderfully happy news that my mother's cancer is in full remission! She's already finished her (localized) radiation therapy and the doctor's prognosis for her is excellent. She's doing great and back to zipping around the country in her little blue car. (My mother and sister are both nutso for driving. They love it.) She's visiting my sister in New England this week and then me and my adorable nub-nieces (whom my first blog posts featured) next week! Yay :)
 


Comments

Mark Raker
06/12/2012 13:41

Please don't lose weight. I still consider size 6 to be a trim woman; size 4 to be skinny enough for any product (it is the size of most department store mannequins after all); with a size 2 I hope that we are not featuring the wardrobe as the proportions are going to look off; and with size 0 I'm forced to do some camouflaging because the clothing just is not going to fit right.

The last important beauty campaign for which I had control over the casting is the shampoo spot that I cast you for. Although we certainly featured your perfect hair I knew that you would be seen head to toe in the spot and I thought your proportions were just right. If you were any thinner your unusual appearance would have alienated the viewers and there goes the whole commercial out the window.

The way you were treated on that salon shoot is just shameful. There is no social or business environment where that kind of behavior can be tolerated. People who genuinely believe they are better than the rest of us because they have figured out how to charge $300 for a haircut are pathetic. When I worked with you I was so impressed by your level of commitment, the amount of preparation you had done, your desire to understand what was expected of you, and your determination to deliver more than was asked. To have some jerks with an overpriced barbershop make you feel bad about yourself is enraging. It has never occurred to me that you needed in any way to alter your appearance and I have seen hundreds of images of you.

Please don't change. And not just because we love you for the sweet person you are, but because I for one can't spend the rest of my career only shooting with Eastern European stick insects whose only skills seem to be the ability to smoke and complain and who need to receive hugs and flowers after every print take.

Reply
06/18/2012 10:26

Hi Mark,

I'm really overwhelmed by all these kind responses, and how much your letter seems to have added to the emotional impact of the issue I was trying to bring up.

To clear up the confusion (for anyone else reading this) I actually worked with Mark on a different hair project, and everyone on the crew was absolutely lovely to me.

I just wanted to say how much this meant to me and how much I appreciate your supportive comments and how generally thoughtful and sweet this entire letter was.

Much love,
Izzy

Reply
06/15/2012 01:27

Hi Izzy (I understand why you gave up Bella after Twilight!),

I was glad to see the previous comment from the photographer (or the man who organized the shoot). Size 4 is slender in the normal world and you look terrific!

I do understand how you feel. The ballet world is so full of size zeros (do they even give out negatives?) and I have always wondered how so much physical energy can be expected from tiny frames. In any case, I have often been ashamed of having feminine hips and thighs, unlike the other ladies in leotards around me. And so, I cringe at my photographs and videos. My blog is actually a sort of healing space where I can slowly get used to seeing my own image. It still isn't easy keeping my eyes open!

- Jenny xxx

Reply
06/18/2012 10:37

Hi Jenny,

As always even your letters inspire me to craft ever more thoughtful posts and thoughtful responses.

I'm so sorry it sounds like you had to go through something similar to what I experienced. I have a few good friends in the city who are dancers, so unfortunately I've heard how similar to modeling/ acting the dance world is, and how it can be just as ridiculous. One of my friends is a ballerina who also does a bit of modeling. She's shorter than me, so she is a size zero (without being at all sickly), and yet she was told over and over again she had the "wrong" body type for being a ballerina. The whole thing is wrong and crazy, and it needs to change. She's a yoga teacher now and still does a bit of dance and that also seems to be a lifestyle that's healing rather than hurting her.

I think it's wonderful that you're finding ways to celebrate your body image. That was part of why I started my blog as well! To look at myself without photoshop and embrace what I see-- "flaws" and all. And to focus myself more on the creative aspects of my own image-- making clothes and finding thriftstore treasures that I could feature here-- rather than focusing on other people's idea of what my image should be and tortuously trying to become that.

I'm so glad you've been sharing your wisdom and insights with me and are helping me out along the way :)

xx
Izzy

Reply
06/16/2012 17:04

Firstly, you look amazing in the photo shoot, the Seventies is my favourite vintage era and so underestimated!
I think most women think or say aloud from time to time that they'd love to lose a little bit of weight. What frustrates me is when others around you just assume you're attention seeking and then loudly declare "you're perfect the way you are"
I went to dance school in London for many years because I loved dancing. I wasn't intending on becoming a professional ballet dancer, I just danced for the love of it and to keep fit.
I really started to notice when I developed hips that I wasn't as thin as the other girls anymore. I used to hate the fact that my gene pool obviously wasn't as good at theirs, who remained like beanstalks.
I wouldn't even say I'm curvy; I'm 5"2 with slight hips. But it's become cultural that female bodily characteristics aren't celebrated as being normal.
Also, there has been, in recent months, a bit of a backlash where TV programmes with style gurus seem to think that they can brand any woman as 'curvy' even when it is clear that they are overweight, which I have a problem with. It's totally unrelated to giving a woman back her confidence, which I'm all for, but I don't condone the media obscuring the importance of exercise over telling someone that they are just naturally curvy.
You actually have a beautiful figure, its feminine, slender and toned, which I think it great. In my eyes, there is nothing better than seeing a woman who have a great athletic body, no matter what their size.
Don't forget what Eleanor Roosevelt said: "No one can make you feel inferior without your consent"
Keep going with the modelling, I strongly believe good things come to those who persevere!
Christobel xx
www.calico-casa.blogspot.co.uk

Reply
06/17/2012 14:18

I've come back to read this again because the first time I read it I knew that if I had commented straight away I wouldn't have been able to stop ranting about how shamefully you had been treated. (I also had to go away and look up what a U.S size zero means in UK sizing). So to come back and to have the additional pleasure of seeing these amazing comments is rather wonderful - especially the one from Mark Raker. The whole size issue has become surreal as well as damaging to individuals. I've only realised as my own body has made the transition from slender teen to curving hips and a dress size that definitely does not conform to industry expectations, how ludicrous and unhealthy those expectations are. Anyway, as I have also been planning for a while to write an article about the modelling industry I would love to interview you about your experiences (positive and negative). Would you be interested? And I also add my voice to those above - I'm SO pleased to see that you have no intention of attempting to lose any weight. Why would you want to when you already look fabulous?

Reply
06/18/2012 10:55

Hi Rosalind,
Thank you for your passionate response. The support I've been getting means a great deal to me. Sorry for the short response I'm starting to run out of steam after replying to everyone's comments. I'll either reply more thoughtfully later on or I'll comment on your blog, but I did want to say I'd be honored to be interviewed about the modeling world in New York. And yes, I do have good things to say about it as well :)
Much love,
Izzy

Reply
Devon
06/19/2012 00:51

You look amazing! Keep being strong for the rest of us!

Reply
Carol
06/19/2012 16:37

What Mark said. Having worked with you in a different context, I couldn't say it better than that! And yes, you should have walked out. Next time... if there is a next time... I hope you will. If you do it from a really centered, solid, self-loving space and with whatever compassion you can muster for the poor folks who are misbehaving, even they will learn something from it.

Reply



Leave a Reply

    bloglovin
    Read the Printed Word!
    Actress, wannabe writer, certified yogi and a true-blue cat lady living in a Brooklyn brownstone with my husband, our animal family and an exponentially expanding thrift store collection of clothes...

    These are my musings on la dolce vita. I shoot with a Canon EOS Rebel T3i.

    Any questions? Please feel free to email me:

    izzydavid@gmail.com
    free counters

    Archives

    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011